Saturday, May 4, 2024

Stoney Creek murder case: Witness takes stand after being wrongfully arrested

First Published:

The Crown prosecutor was building his case Tuesday in the murder trial of Oliver Karafa and Lucy Li. The jury heard evidence from a friend of Karafa’s who was mistakenly arrested for the murder.

As the trial proceedings began, the judge had a message of caution for the jury. One of the lawyers had suggested to a witness that Karafa killed someone as a drunk driver at the age of 19.

“You may not conclude that because Karafa may have had a prior conviction or otherwise had a bad character it is more likely he committed the crimes he is charged with,” Justice Harrison Arrell told the jury.

“You may not reason that … Karafa is the sort of person who would commit the offence here.”

Karafa and Li are charged with first-degree murder in the shooting death of Tyler Pratt and with attempted murder in the shooting of Pratt’s girlfriend Jordyn Romano in Stoney Creek on Feb. 28, 2021.

As the prosecution developed its case Tuesday, it called a friend of Karafa’s to the stand.

The friend, Toronto Chef Phi Chinh, said he agreed to the switch of a so-called SIM identity card in his phone, that could track a phone’s location, with a card from a phone belonging to one of the accused on the day of the murder.

READ MORE: Forensic detective describes what he found at scene of Stoney Creek murder

Chinh testified that he was arrested for the murder 10 months later because of cell phone records until he explained the SIM card switch to the police.

Chinh said he never expected a Sim card belonging to him would be tracked to a murder.

In another development, the Crown presented an agreed statement of fact from a man who appeared to be from Montreal saying he had been negotiating with Karafa to buy a white Range Rover SUV and an older Audi A5.

At first, the evidence said Karafa wanted $30,000 for the vehicles.

According to the statement, he eventually agreed to take a total of $2,000, but insisted the vehicles be sent out of the country.

One text message from Karafa said, “Get rid of it. You will export right? So no trace of them.”

The court has been told that Karafa and Li drove to the scene of the murder in a white Audi and that Romano was shot and injured as she sat in a white Range Rover.

More Top News

Poilievre, Trudeau discuss housing solutions in Hamilton

Canada's top political leaders acknowledged that a solution to Canada's housing crisis is a long way off. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and opposition leader Pierre...

Jewish learning centre opens in Hamilton to educate horrific history

Margaret's Legacy Holocaust Learning & Jewish Advocacy Centre has opened in Hamilton on Main Street West with the idea of educating people on an...

Evening weather forecast for May 3, 2024

Shelly Marriage shares the forecast for May 3, 2024.

Pro-Palestine encampment remains at University of Toronto despite safety concerns

Protesters donned rain ponchos and huddled in tents at a pro-Palestinian encampment at the University of Toronto on Friday as they faced wet and...

Sportsline: Veteran Tiger-Cats player Michael McCarthy

VIDEO: Veteran player personnel executive Michael McCarthy has an excellent eye for talent. The member of the last two Hamilton Tiger-Cats teams to win...

Federal government providing $104M to help Toronto host six 2026 World Cup games

Toronto Mayor Olivia Chow came wearing shin pads, running shoes, soccer scarf and a smile. The federal government came with $104.34 million to help...

Poilievre, Trudeau discuss housing solutions in Hamilton

Canada's top political leaders acknowledged that a solution to Canada's housing crisis is a long way off. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and opposition leader Pierre...